CIBC only bargain among Canadian banks

CIBC is the most exposed bank to the lofty Canadian housing market, but we think there is enough margin of safety in its shares today to compensate for the risks.

Eric Compton 29 August, 2017 | 5:00PM

 

 

Eric Compton: We are just entering the next earnings cycle for Canadian banks, and we believe two key themes will be housing and interest rates.

On housing, we will be paying close attention to delinquency rates, loss rates and loan-to-value ratios, particularly on mortgages within Toronto and Vancouver, which remain the hottest markets within Canada. Last quarter, all of these items remained pristine; however, in late April, the Canadian government increased taxes on foreign homebuyers in Toronto, and since then the market has begun to cool. We will be watching the unwind here, and if it is having any negative effects on the quality of the banks' balance sheets.

Second, we'll be watching the effects from the recent rate rise in July. We will be curious how much this rise will have affected the banks' profitability, and also if it will begin to affect borrowing behavior, particularly among potential mortgagors. The key questions will be if the Canadian economy and the heavily indebted Canadian consumer can indeed handle a rising rate regime.

From a valuation perspective, we view the space as mostly fairly valued, with the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce being the only standout, trading in 4-star territory. CIBC is the most exposed to the Canadian housing market, and, along with the bank's history of blowing itself up once every decade or so, we think this is what is driving the discount in the share price. However, we do believe the market is more than compensating investors for the risk here, particularly if the housing unwind is anything short of a complete disaster.

Securities Mentioned in Article

Security NamePriceChange (%)Morningstar Rating
Bank of Montreal73.46 USD0.14
Bank of Nova Scotia56.26 USD0.09
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce83.68 USD-0.17
Royal Bank of Canada81.31 USD0.91
The Toronto-Dominion Bank57.68 USD0.23

About Author

Eric Compton

Eric Compton  Eric Compton is an equity analyst for Morningstar,