China’s New Gaming Rules Cost Tencent Over $40 Billion in Market Value

The regulations are aimed at curtailing online spending on games, the stock was down more than 12%

Morningstar 22 December, 2023 | 9:54AM
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

Tencent

We are placing NetEase under review following the Chinese government’s release of new draft regulations affecting the gaming sector. Should these rules be put into effect, they could adversely affect the revenue of gaming companies, with NetEase potentially facing considerable challenges. Latest developments have triggered a sharp decline in the stock values of Tencent and NetEase, with shares dropping more than 10% by midday. We believe this market reaction is justified due to the expansive scope of the new draft rules. While these developments could have far-reaching consequences, we are maintaining our current fair value estimates for Tencent and CMGE, as they appear to face a less severe impact from the draft rules. Our position is subject to change as we await further information from gaming companies as to how the new regulations will affect their sales.

Of the many rules in the draft, three are particularly consequential:

  1. Rule 18,
  2. Rule 23, and
  3. Rule 27.

No More Daily Login Rewards or Bonuses

Rule 18 eliminates daily login rewards, bonuses for first-time top-ups, and rewards for consecutive purchases—key elements that drive player engagement and in-app purchasing behavior. The removal of these incentives is likely to reduce daily active users and in-app revenue, and could eventually force publishers to fundamentally overhaul their game design and monetization strategies.

No Converting In-Game Assets Into Real Cash

Rule 23 is set to prohibit publishers from facilitating the conversion of in-game assets into real cash. This is a heavy blow for companies like NetEase, which operate numerous massively multiplayer online role-playing games, or MMORPGs, with intricate economies and a wealth of virtual assets such as gear, currency, and collectibles. Preventing the cash-out of these assets threatens to drain the in-game economy's liquidity and could dissuade players from making investments in virtual goods.

Reduction in Revenue from Loot Boxes

Lastly, Rule 27 mandates that game providers offer players alternative methods to acquire virtual items that are also available in loot boxes. This requirement could diminish the rarity and value of items currently exclusive to loot boxes, which have traditionally been a significant revenue stream for gaming companies.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

Securities Mentioned in Article

Security NamePriceChange (%)Morningstar Rating
NetEase Inc ADR104.97 USD0.73Rating
NetEase Inc Ordinary Shares20.52 USD-1.83
Tencent Holdings Ltd51.29 USD-0.89
Tencent Holdings Ltd ADR51.08 USD-1.14Rating

About Author

Morningstar  Morningstar

© Copyright 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Terms of Use        Privacy Policy       Disclosures        Accessibility